Home > Uncategorized > Salvaging the UPA Gravy Train Wreck

Salvaging the UPA Gravy Train Wreck

Salvaging the UPA Gravy Train Wreck

 

In our last article, Shaelja and I detailed the veritable explosion of government subsidies between 2004-05, when this UPA government took control, and 2011/12.  The following chart makes that obvious at a glance.

 

Subsidies in 000s of crores

 

Between the years 2004-05 and 2011-12, total subsidies grew by a whopping 396% while the GDP increased by a more modest 75%.  When this government assumed charge, subsidies were a modest 1.74% of GDP.  They currently amount to an unsustainable 4.91% of GDP.  Clearly, subsidies have to be cut drastically if bankruptcy on the external and internal debt front is to be avoided.  Is this politically feasible must be the key question agitating the minds of the politicians.  Elections are due in 2014.  Between now and elections, either the ruling party has to put its house in order this year, or postpone reforms to after elections for the next government.  Should reforms be postponed to after elections, it should be obvious the next government will have a huge mess on its hands, with little reserves and no room for maneuver.  Therefore, it is in the interest of all politicians, ruling and opposition who hope to grab power in the next elections, to resolve the mess here and now.   How can it be done?

 

Contrary to the general impression created by our flawed political discourse, most of the incremental subsidies over the levels prevailing at the end of 2004-05 have gone to the well off middle class, rich and the corporate sector.  Subsidies to the poor grew from R25.4 thousand crores to R90.8 thousand crores and at the end of 2011/12 amounted to no more than 1.74% of GDP.  In contrast, subsidies to the rich and corporate sector grew from R28.89 thousand crores to R165.48 thousand crores amounting to over 3.17% of GDP at the end of 2011/12.  Clearly, it is not welfare program for the poor that have led to the explosion in subsidies.  Instead, it is the unwillingness to raise administered prices of goods like petroleum based fuels and fertilizers that antagonize the middle class that have ballooned the subsidy bill.  Political pusillanimity in the face of the powerful, rather than philanthropy for the poor, is the real malaise that grips this government.

 

A glance at the composition of subsidies at the end of 2011-12 makes the steps necessary to resolve the mess obvious.

 

Subsidies in 000s of crores, 2011-12

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Only about R4000 crores of the subsidies on petroleum based fuels go to the poor BPL families.  The rest, amounting to R68.44 thousand crores go the middle and upper classes; people with a marginal savings rate of 30% or more.  Surely, this class of people can pay the economic cost of fuels they use much like their counter-parts in poor countries like Bangladesh and Pakistan.  There is absolutely no economic case for subsidizing petroleum based fuels to anybody except the BPL families.

 

Fertilizer subsidies comprise two parts.  One half is an outright production subsidy to urea manufacturers.  That this subsidy goes to farmers is mere convenient fiction.  With fully depreciated plants, manufacturers have no economic case for continuation of such subsidies.  The other half comprises import subsidies to DAP [Diammonium Phosphate] fertilizers where local production is minimal.  There is global shortage of DAP due to depleting reserves of Phosphates that is never going to go away.  Farmers in any case are given a cost based support price for their produce.  It is far better for government to cutoff subsidies to manufacturers and importers and to instead compensate farmers through higher support prices.  A onetime adjustment in food prices is not inflationary.  In fact it will be deflationary.  Prices will soon settle down and in the long run inflation will come down.

 

No reform can happen unless it benefits the ruling party.  Such is the utter cussedness of our politicians and political system.  So is there some way that a skilled politician like Sonia Gandhi can be made to see direct self-interest in reforms?  Consider.

 

Recall that one of the key reasons for UPA’s victory at the last polls was the bank loan write offs given to farmers.  Can something like that be worked out without increasing net subsidy?  It turns out that you can have a strategy to win 2014 polls through reforms although it means hard work and high political risk.  So let us examine this strategy.

 

The strategy involves the following steps pursued by Sonia Gandhi.  In the ruling party only she has the stature to pull it off successfully and it is in her interest to see this through to completion anyway.

 

  1. 01.  SG should put the full weight of her political authority, in party and government, to implement the Adhar Scheme in manner that payment of subsidies to farmers and BPL families in, at least a few of the Congress ruled States, becomes feasible well before 2014 elections.  Just cut through the bureaucratic infighting and make the UID based scheme for payment of subsidies directly to beneficiaries in cash happen.  Once the poor and the farmers see actual cash in their bank accounts, all argument will cease.  This is the pay off for Congress in its real support base.
  2. 02.  The subsidies to be paid directly to beneficiaries should include food, fuel, and in the case of farmers, urea based fertilizers.  All subsidies to urea manufacturers should be phased out.  Subsidies to DAP importers can continue till a mechanism is designed to pay farmers directly or the cost of the same is included in minimum support price mechanism for food crops.
  3. 03.  Remove all petroleum based subsidies except 1, or at most 2, cylinders per family.  Make consumer pay full price for the LPG and credit the subsidy for the same directly to their bank account.  Consumers who want the subsidy should be asked to fill out a form based on their voter’s card or UID when available to claim the subsidy.  Likewise, self-employed transport operators who oppose reduction in diesel subsidies, should be offered a fixed subsidy in cash for a certain amount of diesel payable into their bank account.  For the rest everybody should pay the economic price of all fuels.

Note, if the government can knock off R68 thousand crores of fuel subsidies and about R25 thousand crores of fertilizer subsidies, the total subsidy bill comes down to R163 thousand crores which is about 3.1% of 2011/12 GDP.

 

Should SG be able to push through the UID scheme and have it implemented in a few Congress ruled states, something entirely feasible given the time frame, she has a good chance of not only eliminating fuel subsidies but also implementing her pet Food Security Bill that she hopes will fetch her more votes.

 

SG will have realized by now that her NAC based agenda, right or wrong, was defeated by simply crowding out the poor by the middle class and the rich snouts at the subsidy trough.  She can push back vigorously using the UID as a tool to focus sharply on the poor and eliminate needless subsidies to the well off. Direct cash payments will empower and enthuse the poor like nothing else.  So the Congress gets a rich harvest of votes.  And the total subsidy bill will have come down from close to 5% of GDP at present to something like 3% of GDP which will give our economy some breathing space to reform and restructure for more sustainable growth.  UID, and elimination of petroleum subsidies, is her key to the next election.

 

Pertinent to note that in case SG and the Congress do not pick up the courage to take the above steps now, the government that takes over in 2014, will have little option but to take these steps anyway.  In other words, for us voters the real choice is between the government doing it now or after elections in 2014.  The earlier the better.  Subsidies are a cancer gnawing away at the vitals of our economy.

 

Growth in subsidies under UPA

 

 

Advertisements
Categories: Uncategorized
  1. No comments yet.
  1. No trackbacks yet.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: